A federal jury trial over a $3.3 million Beckjord greenbelt claim began Nov. 9 in Cincinnati, WCPO reported.

Neighbors Opposed to Pit Expansion alleges Commercial Liability Partners violated a preservation agreement by clearing trees. CLP disputes the agreement’s scope, according to the report.

The retired power-plant property also faces a separate coal-ash lawsuit. The greenbelt damages claim and the county’s environmental allegations should not be treated as a single case or an established finding of liability.

Clermont County announced its federal suit Sept. 24 under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. It names CLP, New Richmond Development Corporation, Duke Energy entities and other companies as defendants.

The county alleges that handling and disposal of ash in unlined ponds endangers public health and the environment. It says the Ohio River site lies upgradient from wellfields in Pierce, Union and Batavia townships serving about 145,000 residents.

The county’s complaint also alleges that sulfate contamination caused one public-supply well to be permanently removed from service. These are the county’s allegations; the filing is not a court ruling that proves them.

In its 2018 sale announcement, Duke Energy said the plant had retired in 2014. Duke and its co-owners sold the property, including ash ponds, to CLP. The announcement described planned decommissioning and environmental work; it does not establish that the work is complete today.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency describes coal ash as waste from burning coal. It can contain mercury, cadmium and arsenic that may pollute water without proper management. That general risk does not establish current contamination at any particular household tap.

A verdict in the greenbelt trial has not been verified. The materials cited here do not establish the defendants’ response to the separate county complaint.